[Grumpy would be me, not the long-suffering soul to whom I am wed.]
December is our month to send in charitable donations. We do all gifts in one big batch, because it makes the deciding and record-keeping that much easier.
So the other night the SuperHusband and I sit down for our evening couple time after kids are in bed, and I’m roving through the topics, mostly just exercising my not-so-inner curmudgeon. No lofty goals intended. I mention this blog post about expat parties in Haiti. My conclusion is this: But really, we’re the same way. I feel bad for all those poor people, but that doesn’t mean I shouldn’t have my beer.
And SuperHusband, who is a generous and charitable person, says: I’m not sure aid to Haiti really helps.
I concede that there are no doubt problems in Haiti that no amount of aid will fix, but that certain projects, especially certain Christian humanitarian mission projects, are helping.
SuperHusband brings in North Korea. If you send money to North Korea, it only supports the corrupt regime, and no starving people are saved.
I suspect he is probably correct, but point out that we talking about Haiti tonight, not North Korea.
SuperHusband says that UN aid to Haiti is helping maintain the status quo.
I agree, but observe that for all a UN water truck might discourage the local government from building its own water treatment plant, for the person who will be dead tomorrow without clean water, it might be nice to live long enough to agitate for reform. But in any case, I am not proposing we send money to the UN. I would like to send money to some Christian missionaries.
SuperHusband says that he does not believe change can happen from without. That people must decide for themselves they want change. Therefore, outside aid is not helpful.
Yes, I say. I have discovered that every time I try to work through a major policy problem, I keep coming back to how the answer is Jesus.
Yes, he says.
And isn’t it interesting, I say, how the New Testament doesn’t tell us to send extra money to government aid programs. But curiously, it does tell us Christians to provide for the poor ourselves. Pure religion is this: providing for the widow and the orphan.
And he says okay. Send some money to missionaries.
Sounds about like our evening couple time.
I don’t actually usually try to talk him into things. Well, okay maybe.
Do you read Amy Scott’s blog? Check this out: http://humblemusings.com/?p=2575#comments
Thanks for the link. Yes, covering familiar territory in that conversation.